PC Mohammad Bhatti Pleads Selective Amnesia for Lies He Told on Police Vetting Forms

A Metropolitan Police officer has been dismissed without notice after an accelerated misconduct hearing found he deliberately withheld information about a drink-driving and firearms investigation he was subject to as far back as 2008.

PC Mohammad Bhatti had worked for the Metropolitan Police for over 20 years, joining as a PCSO in 2003 before becoming a police constable in 2009. In June 2020, he was required to complete a vetting renewal. The form required officers to declare arrests and investigations, and warned that withholding information could lead to disciplinary action. PC Bhatti nonetheless indicated ‘no’ when asked whether he had ever been investigated or arrested by any UK or non-UK police force. However, it emerged that Bhatti had been involved in two substantial incidents involving the police.

On 12th August 2008, the PNC showed that Bhatti was arrested at 05:15 for ‘driving a motor vehicle with excess alcohol’. He had crashed his vehicle into a set of railings and, upon exiting the vehicle, called 999. The matter resulted in no further action because, when breathalysed, Bhatti was below the limit. Bhatti claimed that the reason he had not declared the incident on the vetting form was that he did not remember being arrested, or being subject to any form of investigation. As part of his response to the regulation notice served against him for dishonesty, Bhatti accepted he had been in a single-vehicle collision, but claimed that he suffered a head injury, which caused him to lose consciousness. He told the hearing he remembered calling the emergency services and remembered being in an ambulance, as well as ‘vaguely’ remembering ‘coming round’ in hospital. But, despite remembering those details, he said he did not recall speaking to police at the scene, did not remember being arrested, and could not recall whether he had provided a blood sample or taken a breath test. He did admit that he had been discharged from hospital the same day and given paracetamol to take.

The second allegation concerned a 2011–2012 investigation involving Sussex Police and Greater Manchester Police. At that time, police intelligence recorded a complaint from an ex-partner alleging that she had been threatened by Bhatti with two pistols. Sussex Police did not pursue domestic abuse allegations, but concerns about firearms led to a search warrant being obtained and executed at Bhatti’s address on 16th June 2012. Two imitation firearms were located, and Bhatti later attended a voluntary interview at Crawley Police Station, with a federation representative present, where he explained why he was in possession of the imitation firearms. On this allegation, Bhatti accepted he had not completed the 2020 vetting form ‘accurately’, but tried to frame it as error rather than concealment. He said he had misunderstood what the form was asking, and blamed the circumstances in which he completed it, claiming he had been working ‘consecutive early turns’.

When questioned by the Chair about reporting the incident internally, Bhatti said he had informed his supervisor ‘verbally’ at the time, but could not recall whether he had informed Professional Standards.

In cross-examination, Bhatti said he was unable to recall whether he had undertaken the vetting process on each of his previous applications to become a police constable, suggesting he believed the form only arose after passing an earlier stage. On the practical consequences of the 2008 crash, he could recall that police removed his vehicle because it was not drivable and that he later liaised with his insurer, yet he said he did not know where the car had been taken.

Commander Lilburn rejected the thrust of Bhatti’s position. She found there was a clear obligation to disclose the 2008 arrest and investigation, and concluded it was more likely than not that Bhatti would have known about his arrest at the time and would have recalled it when completing the 2020 form. She pointed out that he remembered a lot of detail in relation to the 2008 collision, including damaging the railings and making the 999 call himself. As the arrest took place half an hour after the accident, she concluded it was clear that Bhatti was in a fit state and was not suffering from concussion.

On the firearms matter, she found there was plainly an investigation and that the form’s instructions were clear. She placed limited weight on his claimed working pattern and concluded the omissions were deliberate. The Chair found breaches of honesty and integrity, discreditable conduct, and orders and instructions, and determined the conduct amounted to gross misconduct.

In mitigation, the hearing heard that Bhatti had received commendations and strong character support from colleagues, including references to his professionalism on demanding frontline duties. Even so, the Chair concluded that a final written warning would be insufficient given the seriousness of undermining the vetting process, describing the harm to public confidence and the reputation of the Metropolitan Police as high.

Bhatti was dismissed without notice and directed to be placed on the barred list.

OP-ED

This outcome leaves two obvious questions unanswered. Why did the Met Police not perform even the most basic PNC check when processing Bhatti’s 2020 vetting form? And how long was Bhatti allowed to continue serving as a police officer before his lies were exposed?

So either those who process these vetting forms were negligent, or the police treat their own officers very differently from how they treat ordinary members of the public who are routinely made subject to criminal record checks as part of their employment.

SUBSCRIBE

Subscribe to receive special offers, advance order access and notifications about our latest articles and campaigns.