DS Andrew Kilpatrick Sacked For ‘Throwing Down’ Female Self-Defence Trainer During Training Exercise

A Metropolitan police officer has been dismissed without notice after a misconduct panel concluded that he deliberately assaulted a female police trainer during a routine training session.

On 12th August 2022, DS Andrew Kilpatrick attended Hendon Police College to undertake a PPST refresher course. The course started with a video titled ‘Hold the Line’ in a first-floor classroom, following which the attendees moved downstairs to the ‘dojo’ for a physical exercises’ session. They were practising the Spontaneous Protection Enabling Accelerated Response (SPEAR Flow Drill) technique: a single arm defensive tactic that simulates a static push away using a single forearm to effectively keep the assailant from making contact.

PPST Trainer PS Fairburn noticed that the technique being employed by DS Kilpatrick and his partner during this exercise was incorrect. She approached the pair and attempted to demonstrate the correct technique. It is alleged that as she demonstrated this on DS Kilpatrick’s partner, DS Kilpatrick stepped in and, without warning, grabbed hold of PS Fairburn’s arm, passed it to the side, and conducted a full takedown on her. PS Fairburn was winded, injuring her thumb and elbow. She challenged DS Kilpatrick immediately, saying, “that was bang out of order”.

PS Fairburn described feeling threatened and bewildered that, in a professional training environment, a senior officer would escalate a demonstration into what she regarded as an assault. She claimed that the takedown had caused her psychological distress and that she was shocked by the suddenness and aggression of it. She noted that no apology was forthcoming from DS Kilpatrick, and that he continued to act in an arrogant and condescending manner, advising instructors that their technique was wrong throughout the training session.

DS Kilpatrick initially suggested he believed he was acting in self-defence, as he thought he was about to be struck by PS Fairburn. He also claimed that music played during the training session was too loud for him to make out what was being said by the trainers. The panel rejected his explanation, finding it to be an after-the-fact rationalisation rather than a credible account of events.

Witnesses described DS Kilpatrick’s conduct as belligerent in the moments that followed. Rather than showing concern or offering an apology, he took issue with the technique being taught and repeatedly sought to demonstrate how he believed it ‘should’ be done. One trainer said he approached with his chest puffed out ‘as if to display dominance’. Another recounted that his tone was assertive and confrontational, more focused on proving a point than acknowledging the harm caused.

The panel also heard that earlier in the day DS Kilpatrick had not been paying attention during a training video, choosing instead to use his laptop. During subsequent exercises, he was said to have obstructed demonstrations by resisting instructors when he should have allowed techniques to be applied, behaviour which further fuelled concerns about his attitude and professionalism.

On the balance of probabilities, the panel concluded that the assault was not an instinctive or accidental misjudgement but a deliberate act. It rejected any suggestion that this was ‘muscle memory’ kicking in. Instead, the finding was that he made a conscious decision to use force in circumstances where none was required. In weighing culpability, the panel emphasised his seniority and experience – over 27 years’ service – raising, rather than lowering, the standards expected of him.

In light of its findings, the Panel determined that the appropriate and proportionate sanction was dismissal without notice. DS Andrew Kilpatrick will also be added to the College of Policing Barred List.

SUBSCRIBE

Subscribe to receive special offers, advance order access and notifications about our latest articles and campaigns.